Solution section
Critiques
Open questions, objections and unresolved design issues.
Critiques
Key questions include:
- Are regional settlement prices too geographically coarse?
- Does five-minute central optimisation provide sufficient responsiveness?
- How should wholesale energy value and local network value interact?
- Who calculates dynamic envelopes and from what network model?
- How should scarce network headroom be allocated?
- What communications and interoperability are required?
- Can consumers and devices understand multiple dynamic signals?
- Does layering dynamic access beside wholesale pricing create coordination conflicts?
The architecture is especially useful as a comparator because it combines mature real-time wholesale operation with an emerging digital distribution layer.